Day 19: Innovation that Meets Needs

This March I’m “slicing” a piece of my teaching day every day with Two Writing Teachers’ Slice of Life Challenge.11454297503_e27946e4ff_h

Margaret Simon at Reflections on the Teche posted this as the topic for DigiLit Sunday.

digilitsunday-innovation.png I am still pondering the quote. Thinking versus doing. In many cases, thinking would precede doing, but maybe not. Maybe there are some who first do and then think. Hmm. Perhaps it is an iterative process.

Another idea around innovation I found on Wikipedia credited to Steven Maranville. “…innovation is often also viewed as the application of better solutions that meet new requirements, unarticulated needs, or existing market needs.” A marketer’s viewpoint, but also one that exists in a teaching life.

Better solutions that meet requirements and needs.

Unarticulated needs intrigue me. We are so busy meeting curricular demands and those glaring classroom needs that the unarticulated needs are often overlooked.

These are the students that sit quietly.  They don’t demand attention. In a busy classroom, these kiddos are undercover.

I walk up to V. Her book and notebook are open, pens, highlighters, and lead pencils are neatly lined beside her notebook.  She is quietly making perfect little boxes out of the square post-its provided for jots about reading. A bit of glitter has been placed in one of the boxes.

How is that book going?

Guilty looks.

This is a student who can read and access grade level texts when a teacher or parent is there. But left to her own devices, she will only engage deeply with graphic novels.

Many teachers have felt that V needs an IEP. Initially, she presents in this way. She is slow to talk and engage with classmates; she is reluctant to write and open a book. She’d rather operate in her own little world. But discussions with V show understanding and intelligence.  Open-ended requests to share what she noticed in a book and she lights up. Running records show her to be a very close to grade level.

The trouble with V and all the kiddos like her is that she is a child who moves to her own drummer. She is creative; filled with ideas and passions that don’t fit school expectations. She resists, quietly. And, she could go undetected in a large middle school classroom. Only calling attention to herself with missing homework.What to do? 

We innovate.

Our agreement is as long as she’s reading and writing, it can be on her terms.  She understands school requires assignments and tests. We meet. We modify her assignments. Currently, V is close to meeting reading and writing expectations. Which is great. I don’t worry about her literacy. What concerns me are the educational cracks she could fall through down the road. Will she get to do the things she is interested in and uniquely skilled to do?  

The system isn’t designed for V. And it makes me wonder, how many students are just like V.


4 thoughts on “Day 19: Innovation that Meets Needs

  1. I’ve had students like this often through the years, and each one really does march to a different beat, often not too far behind, sometimes “just” meeting the expectations. I read the book The Day I Became an “autodidact” a long time ago (self taught) & wondered if these kinds of students would be learning more if left to their own devices? I definitely counseled parents to be aware that they need to check in with the teacher(s) often. Thanks, Julieanne!

  2. I’ve had that student, the creative, quiet one who wants to be unnoticed. Your gentle hand in allowing her choice is going to help her through.

  3. My thoughts went in a similar direction when I read that Wikipedia quote. I think teachers are masters of micro-innovations: thinking in the moment about what will work for this child. I hope in the future V. has teachers who are as thoughtful and reflective as you, Julieanne!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s