Day 28: What would you rather write?

This March I’m “slicing” a piece of my teaching day every day with the Two Writing Teachers community.11454297503_e27946e4ff_h

I polled my students today as they wrote their opinions on space exploration.

If you could choose, what would you rather write, a narrative, an informational piece or an opinion?

Approximately half of the students would rather write narrative and half preferred opinion writing. Only two students choose informational as an equal to story or argument writing. My next question was, why?

Narrative lovers said:

  • you get to think of what you want characters to do
  • you can plan out how you want it to be
  • it feels like you are in the story and you have to find the solution
  • you don’t have to do as much research
  • it’s fun!

Students want to dive into stories. Create the problem, find the solution. They are only limited by what they can imagine. That’s why fantasy is a blast. It not only allows them to create characters but also make impossible beings and situations. Why don’t I do more of this?

Argument lovers said:

  • you can write about what you think
  • my opinion matters
  • you can choose your side
  • research is fun

Students have opinions about all kinds of things and having the opportunity to put those feelings out in the world is an incredible feeling. What I heard again, and again was, “I can choose what I think!” Power for those who might feel powerless from time to time is intoxicating.

The few informational lovers said:

  • it tells what is true
  • research is fun

For this group of kiddos, informational writing is a difficult sell. Maybe it minimizes them. Maybe their research skills are underdeveloped and they find the facts boring to retell. Perhaps when they are more adept in research techniques they will be able to see that “facts” aren’t always simple and the “truth,” according to them, needs to be told.

This informal survey of sixty shows me a few things about the writing lives of my kiddos.

First, students love control.
Second, choice and voice are premium commodities.
Third, they want to play and have fun with writing.

A simple question offers  a lot of insight. It tells me where joy lies and what needs to be supported.

I want students to write. And write.

I want to see them light up when it’s time to write and complain when we have to put it away.

I want them to ask if they can work on it at home.

Every group of students tells a different story. And the story changes throughout the year. It’s important to remind myself that within all of the complicated work we do, with all the high expectations, to remember to ask the simple questions that can drive what comes next.





16 thoughts on “Day 28: What would you rather write?

  1. What an insightful survey you’ve shared with your students and us slicers! I also agree, my students would much rather write narratives or opinion pieces! And your students expressed very well the WHY behind this!

  2. What a great – and revealing – question to ask. I also love how you use their responses to reflect on your practices as a writing teacher (“Why don’t I do more of this?”) I might steal this for my kids’ Civil War writing projects.

  3. Your simple question shows how much you value choice in your classroom. I think mine would choose narrative, but I should ask.

  4. I see your “First…Second…Third…” as your sample table of contents for the book you could/should write about working with students in reading and writing workshop. I truly do see you writing a book that honestly shares what it looks like and sounds like in a classroom. Just a little nudge today!! Your blog, revised, would be so helpful in the hands of teachers as a book (in my opinion!) Thanks for reminding me today of the 3 things kids love and need.

  5. The power of a simple question and the implications for teaching from the answers. I will second Sally’s thoughts on you writing a book. Yes, it’s one that needs to be written, by you.

  6. This is a powerful open ended question. It is so interesting how it can take the pulse of a group. Very cool, simple idea for any age!

  7. I agree about the book, too, Julieanne. You are so clear about your actions and what you do with the results in the future. Young teachers especially need to hear those words. One thing I really loved that you wrote today is that every group is different, so one must continue to ask those questions, and throughout the year, too! Thanks for sharing this group’s answers.

  8. You make great points. How can we offer more voice and choice around types of writing while still keeping instruction manageable for a class of 20+ writers? Maybe it’s, as you did today, offering a few days at a time throughout the year to dabble in the type of writing they choose…perhaps a mini or micro unit of study.

  9. They may be simple, but they are great questions to guide instruction. I pondered the results and wonder if perhaps more students prefer narrative and opinion because the writer can put himself into that kind of writing easier than in informational text.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s